Dr Makary: CDC steering on Chickenpox vaccine exposes company’s contradictory COVID messaging

Dr. Marty Makary on Tuesday accused the Facilities for Illness Management and Prevention of “cherry-picking” information and manipulating public well being steering surrounding vaccines and pure immunity to assist a political narrative. 

Makary, a professor of surgical procedure and well being coverage on the Johns Hopkins College and Fox Information medical contributor, joined the “Clay Travis and Buck Sexton Present” to debate the medical affect of pure immunity because it compares to the vaccine.


Travis famous that the CDC’s steering on COVID-19 is inconsistent with their vaccine suggestions for different contagious viruses. The present steering for the Chickenpox, for instance, doesn’t encourage those that have contracted it to vaccinate themselves in opposition to the virus. 

“CDC recommends two doses of chickenpox vaccine for youngsters, adolescents, and adults who’ve by no means had chickenpox,” the official web site reads. 

“So why doesn’t CDC say the identical factor about these of us who already had COVID?” Travis requested.

Makary known as the conflicting steering “completely illogical,” and accused the company of “ignoring pure immunity. 

“It would not make sense with what they’re placing out on Chickenpox,” he mentioned. “It is like they’ve adopted the immune system to the Democrat Social gathering for one virus, however not for an additional virus.”

“They cherry-pick the information to assist no matter they’ve already determined,” he continued. “They salami slice it, one thing we name fishing in statistical methods. That’s once you search for a tiny sliver of knowledge that helps what you already consider.”

U.S. Surgeon Normal Vivek Murthy was asked throughout a Fox Information Q&A session earlier this month whether or not dad and mom ought to intentionally expose their youngsters to COVID-19 “to offer them a pure immunity, like we do with the Chickenpox in our house.”


Murthy mentioned that whereas it’s a “cheap query to ask,” he encourages dad and mom to vaccinate their youngsters as there could be “different issues” that come up from contracting the virus.

“The numerous factor is for us to weigh dangers and advantages right here,” he mentioned. “After we do this, we see that getting vaccinated is definitely a a lot decrease threat and better profit proposition than permitting our youngsters to get COVID and run the danger of getting issues.”

Supply hyperlink